Top 5 Pizzerias in Toronto that serve a New York style pie
Toronto is a food lover's paradise, offering an incredible variety of flavours within walking distance when dining out in this diverse city. Whether you're seeking out hidden gems with no phone or indulging in luxurious tasting menus, Toronto's dining scene has something for everyone.
And today we will focus on Toronto's best pizzerias which dish up the perfect New York-style pizza, resulting in mind-bending delicious pies that you simply have to try. Whether it’s take-out, dine-in or by the slice, this list will definitely keep you coming back for more.
Let’s get into it.
1. Mac’s Pizza
Mac's Pizza in Dovercourt is an ode to the perfect New York slice with a twist. The garlic cream sauce pies are a testament to Mac's Pizza's unique creations which showcase their ability to take classic ingredients and elevate them to a whole new level. The Potato Pie, topped with delicate potato slices and spicy Calabrian chilli, is a fan favourite that delivers a perfect balance of heat and creaminess. The White Pie, on the other hand, features a delectable combination of sweet and savoury flavours, with caramelized onions, mushrooms, and honey drizzled over the rich garlic cream sauce.
Relatively new to the Toronto Pizzeria scene, Mac’s is here to stay and as their popularity continues to soar, it won’t be hard to imagine crowds forming outside the restaurant just to get a taste of their delectable slices.
2. Pizzeria Badiali
Speaking of crowds forming outside the restaurant - Pizzeria Badiali is a must-visit destination for any true pizza lover looking to explore the diverse and vibrant culinary landscape of Toronto. Despite being situated off the beaten path of West Queen West, it has become a beloved local haunt among residents who appreciate its exceptional quality and flavour. While it may not be on the radar of tourists and casual passersby, it is a perfect spot for an intimate dinner or casual night out with friends . Some of the most popular pies at the pizzeria include the Burrata Marinara, Vodka Pie, Original Cheese, and Mushroom Bianco, all of which have gained a devoted following among customers.
3. Superpoint
Superpoint is my personal grab-and-go pizzeria. Located on the Ossington strip in Toronto, Superpoint is a bustling and lively pizzeria that never fails to impress. The extensive menu has something for every pizza lover, whether you want classic toppings or more experimental flavour combinations like the "Funghi" with roasted mushrooms and truffle oil. Beyond the food, Superpoint has a vibe that's hard to beat. The lively decor and welcoming staff make it the ideal spot for a quick hangout with friends or a relaxed night out. And if pizza isn't your thing, don't worry; there are plenty of other Italian-inspired dishes on offer, along with an impressive selection of wines and cocktails.
4. Bar Sugo
Ready to indulge in some of the best New York-style pizza Toronto has to offer? From the culinary masterminds behind Sugo, a quintessential pasta restaurant on Bloor St. W, comes a new restaurant that's making waves in the pizza scene. Bar Sugo is quicky earning its spot at the top with hometown favourites such as their Margueretta Pizza, Little Italy, Uncle Scotty and The Conzo made with their house-special rose sauce. Their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and a crispy thin crust that adds an extra crunch to each bite. But Bar Sugo isn't just about the pizza. The restaurant also offers a wide selection of delicious Italian dishes, including homemade pastas, fresh salads, and mouth-watering desserts. The cozy and intimate atmosphere of the restaurant makes it the perfect spot for a romantic date night or a casual dinner with friends.
5. North of Brooklyn Pizzeria
With multiple locations in Toronto, North of Brooklyn Pizzeria started off its journey on Queen Street W, where it quickly became a local favourite serving up classics like NY Cheese, Truffle Shuffle, Green Out and Vodka Verde. Their commitment to quality ingredients and traditional cooking methods has earned them a loyal following, and also the highest score pizzeria in Toronto by Dave Portnoy. Their expanding menu continues to draw in new fans looking for a taste of their unique and delicious pizzas.
Don’t agree with the list? Share your top picks here.